Cashless payments offer customers the convenience of quick transactions without needing physical currency. This streamlines purchases and reduces the risk of theft. In 2023, cash accounted for 12% of POS system transactions and only 1% of all eCommerce transactions in the US.
However, card purchases bring in extra costs for business owners (e.g., cost of processing, merchant service fees, and additional fees like chargeback fees, compliance fees, equipment fees, monthly fees, etc.) that cut into profit margins.
Reliance on credit card payments can also make businesses vulnerable to technical issues or outages, potentially disrupting their operations and affecting customer satisfaction.
Even so, small businesses can’t afford to ignore card payments in today’s economic landscape. What they can do is implement cash discount programs, incentivizing customers to pay by cash, and helping offset the cost of credit card processing.
TL;DR
- A cash discount program is a pricing strategy in which businesses offer customers a discount on the posted price of an item if they choose to pay by cash. This encourages cash transactions and helps merchants lower their credit card processing fees, ultimately improving their bottom line.
- In cash discounting, posted prices of all items are card prices (with payment processing fees already built into them). Customers paying by cash are eligible for a discount (that equals the merchant processing fees). In the case of surcharging, listed prices are cash prices, and a service fee or surcharge is added if a customer pays by card.
- Implementing a cash discount program can offer businesses numerous benefits, from reducing transaction fees to incentivizing cash transactions. However, it’s essential to remain vigilant about compliance with regulations and responsive to customer feedback.
What Is a Cash Discount Program?
| Cash Discounting | Surcharging | |
| Definition | Offers a discount on posted prices if paid by cash | Adds a fee to the posted price if paid by card |
| Listed Prices | Card prices with processing fees included | Cash prices without processing fees included |
| Customer Perception | Seen as a reward for paying with cash | Seen as a cost for paying with card |
| Legal Considerations | Must adhere to local, state, and federal regulations | Must adhere to local, state, and federal regulations |
| Communication | Requires clear communication about the discount program | Requires clear communication about the surcharge program |
| Receipt Details | Discount shown as a separate line item | Surcharge shown as a separate line item |
A cash discount program is a pricing strategy in which businesses offer customers a discount on the posted price of an item if they choose to pay by cash instead of electronic payment solutions like credit or debit cards.
This encourages cash transactions and helps merchants lower their credit card processing fees, ultimately improving their bottom line.
How a cash discount works
A cash discount can be applied to various types of purchases, including both in-store and online transactions. Here’s how it works.
If a merchant has set up cash discounting at their store, the posted prices of all items will be card prices. In other words, the listed prices will already have payment processing fees (for credit and debit card transactions) built into them.
At checkout, a customer who pays by cash will be eligible for a discount (that equals the merchant processing fees). Essentially, the cash price is the credit price minus the service fee a merchant would otherwise charge to offset the cost of processing cards, which appears as a cash discount line item on the receipt.
This is a win-win for both the customer and the retailer. The customer gets to pay a lower price on their purchase and the business gets to avoid credit card fees.
As such, transparency is of utmost importance in a true cash discount program. Using proper signage, the customer has to be made fully aware of the discount they’ll receive if they pay with cash, and that they still have the option to pay by card, except they will be paying a higher price—the posted price.
Cash Discount vs Surcharge
A cash discount is a reduction in price merchants offer customers who pay with cash or a cash equivalent, which incentivizes cash transactions and offsets processing fees. Conversely, a surcharge fee is an additional fee that businesses impose on customers who pay with credit or debit cards, to cover the cost of card processing.
Both strategies aim to adjust pricing based on the payment method but in opposing ways. In the case of surcharging, listed prices are actually cash prices. If a customer pays by card, a service fee or surcharge will be added to the listed price and appear on the receipt as a separate line item.
Businesses can decide between cash discounting and surcharge programs based on their priorities and customer preferences. Cash discounting and surcharging can be offered together but merchants need to understand their legality and ensure compliance with card brand or card network (e.g. Visa, Mastercard, etc.) rules.
Some jurisdictions have specific laws or regulations regarding surcharges or cash discounts, so it’s essential to understand and adhere to these guidelines. Also, clear communication with customers about price changes is crucial for building trust and ensuring legal compliance.
Benefits of Cash Discount Programs
Implementing cash discount programs has several advantages:
- Cost-saving for merchants – Cash discounts enable businesses to reduce expenses associated with card processing fees, preserving more revenue from each transaction. By incentivizing cash payments, merchants can mitigate the impact of transaction fees on their bottom line, ultimately increasing profitability and financial sustainability.
- Incentive for cash transactions – Cash discounts motivate customers to opt for cash payments, fostering efficient transactions without incurring additional processing costs. This encourages the use of physical currency, streamlining the payment process and potentially reducing reliance on electronic payment systems, thereby enhancing operational efficiency for both merchants and customers.
- Increased profit margins – Implementing cash discounts can lead to higher profit margins for merchants by reducing the overhead costs associated with credit card transactions. With discounts for cash payments, businesses can retain more of their revenue, thereby bolstering their financial health and creating opportunities for investment, growth, and sustainability in the long term.
Implementing a Cash Discount Program
Implementing a cash discount program can offer businesses numerous benefits, from reducing transaction fees to incentivizing cash transactions. Here’s a step-by-step guide to effectively introduce and manage a cash discount program.
Understand regulations
Research local, state, and federal regulations regarding cash discounts to ensure compliance with laws governing pricing practices and payment methods. Consult legal experts if necessary to understand specific requirements or restrictions applicable to your business.
Determine discount amount
Analyze your profit margins, expenses, and customer behavior to determine an appropriate discount percentage or fixed amount that balances incentivizing cash payments with maintaining profitability. Consider factors such as average transaction value and competitive pricing in your industry.
Update pricing structure
Adjust your product pricing to reflect the cash discount, ensuring that the discounted price is clearly displayed alongside the regular price for transparency. Update your point-of-sale system and marketing materials to reflect the new pricing structure accurately.
Train staff
Provide comprehensive training to your staff on the cash discount program—how to explain it to customers, calculate discounts accurately, and handle cash transactions securely. Emphasize the importance of maintaining professionalism and customer service throughout the payment process.
Communicate with customers
Launch a marketing campaign to inform customers about the new cash discount program through various channels such as signage in-store, email newsletters, social media posts, and updates on your website. Clearly communicate the benefits of paying with cash and any changes to pricing or payment options.
Offer payment options
Ensure that your business accepts multiple forms of payment, including cash, credit/debit cards, and possibly mobile payment methods, to accommodate customer preferences. Display prominent signage indicating accepted payment methods and any associated fees or discounts.
Monitor and adjust
Regularly track the performance of your cash discount program, including its impact on sales volume, transaction value, and customer satisfaction. Solicit feedback from customers and staff to identify any issues or areas for improvement, and be prepared to adjust the program as needed to optimize results.
Stay compliant
Stay informed about changes in regulations related to cash discounts and payment processing, and update your policies and procedures accordingly to remain compliant. Regularly review your cash discount program to ensure it aligns with legal requirements and industry standards.
Final Words
Cash discounting offers businesses a strategic approach to managing payment processing costs while incentivizing cash transactions. However, it’s essential to remain vigilant about compliance with regulations and responsive to customer feedback.
With careful planning and execution, cash discounting can not only streamline financial operations but also enhance customer satisfaction and bolster long-term profitability.
Remember that a true cash discount program is one in which the customer pays less than the listed price at checkout. If a customer pays more than the listed price, it qualifies as a surcharge program regardless.
If you decide that surcharging might be the better option, choose a payment solution provider like CardX by Stax that can help you implement it easily while ensuring compliance with all applicable laws and rules. Contact us to learn more.
Request a Quote
